Skip to content
Man in navy tuxedo and bow tie, tinted glasses and white beard, posing in front of Emmy, Variety and MIPCOM logos.

Ece Üner Hits Back at Haluk Bilginer's 'Cinema of Turkey' Remarks

Haluk Bilginer's years-old remark that 'Turkish cinema doesn't feel right to me' resurfaced on 9 November and sparked debate. Ece Üner, Fatih Altaylı and Gökhan Özoğuz weighed in.

2 min read

Photo: nirvanahaber.com

Veteran actor Haluk Bilginer's remarks on how cinema should be named, made in an interview years ago, became a talking point when they were reshared on social media on 9 November. Journalist and news anchor Ece Üner reacted sharply to his suggestion of saying “cinema of Turkey” instead of “Turkish cinema”.

Man in navy tuxedo and bow tie, tinted glasses and white beard, posing in front of Emmy, Variety and MIPCOM logos.
nirvanahaber.com

What did Bilginer say?

In the earlier interview, Bilginer said he did not find “Turkish cinema” the right term for films made in Turkey. He said, “Shall we call it cinema of Turkey? Turkish cinema doesn't feel right to me.” The resurfaced footage reignited the debate over whether cinema should be named by national identity or by geography.

Another strand of the debate was a report that in a different talk Bilginer used the phrases “British, French, Russian cinema”. Some commentators found it inconsistent to say “cinema of Turkey” while using identity-based names for other countries. Journalist Mehmet Çek argued that “cinema of Turkey” and “Turkiyeli” are artificial definitions.

A sharp response from Ece Üner

In a post on her social media account, Ece Üner wrote that saying “cinema of Turkey” instead of “Turkish cinema” is “outright racism”. In another post she recalled Mustafa Kemal Atatürk's words “How happy is the one who says I am a Turk”. Noting that Atatürk did not say “How happy is the one of Turkish race”, Üner argued that the saying answered racism debates in the past.

Journalist Fatih Altaylı also assessed Bilginer's approach through the naming of other countries' cinemas. Citing French and Iranian cinema as examples, Altaylı questioned Bilginer's stance on such labels.

Voices from the arts world

Singer Yeşim Salkım and Athena frontman Gökhan Özoğuz also joined in. Özoğuz said Turkey is the name of a country while being Turkish is an identity, defending terms such as “Turkish cinema”, “Turkish history” and “Turkish culture”.

Haluk Bilginer is one of the best-known names in theatre, film and television, familiar to wide audiences through the film Winter Sleep and the series Şahsiyet. That is why his old remarks drew wide attention so quickly. No new statement from Bilginer on the matter has been shared so far. A naming preference voiced years ago has thus grown into a broader debate about identity and culture.

Comments

See All

Keep exploring

We use necessary cookies to run the site. With your permission, we also use analytics cookies to improve it, advertising cookies to show ads, and embed cookies to load outside content like videos. You can change your choice at any time. Cookie policy