
Attentive over text, distant in person: Why are we so inconsistent when flirting? Serra and Kerem explain
Long midnight messages, heart emojis, "I'm so curious about you"... then a cold face once you sit down for coffee. Serra turns to the women, Kerem to the men: Where does this inconsistency in flirting come from, when should you care, and when should you walk away?
Photo: Yapay zekâ ile üretilmiştir
This piece is a first. Serra grabbed her coffee, Kerem his whiskey, and they sat down at the same table. The topic is the question filling both their inboxes: "Over text it feels like they adore me, but face to face it's like someone else. Why?"
Question from a reader: "I've been messaging someone for two weeks. We text for hours at night, and they tell me, 'Talking to you feels so good.' We met up last week; they looked at their phone, gave short answers, and left after an hour. Once they got home, they wrote long messages again. What did I misunderstand?"
Serra: "Girls, writing is easy, sitting across from someone is hard"
Honey, first know this: You didn't misunderstand anything. You met two different people. One behind the screen, one across the table.
Over text, everyone is a bit bolder, a bit wittier, a bit more romantic. You can think before you write, fix your sentence, and reply half an hour later if you need to. Nobody sees your face turn red. But once you're at the table, there's nowhere to hide. There's eye contact, there's silence, there's "What do I say now?"
Some people can't handle this transition. They can't carry the character they built on screen into real life. This isn't always bad intent; sometimes it's plain shyness, sometimes insecurity.
But girls, knowing this doesn't mean you have to put up with it.
Kerem: "Guys, we do this a lot"
Dear Serra, you're right, and I'll admit it: We men are the biggest representatives of this inconsistency. I've done it too.
Let me tell you why men do this:
- We're in control on screen. Over text we write when we want and go quiet when we want. Face to face, that control is gone. Some of us don't like that.
- The attention in texts is sometimes not real, it's habit. Looking at your phone before bed and writing to someone eases loneliness a little. It doesn't mean we actually want something with that person. It hurts to admit, but it's true.
- Fear of expectations. Everything is imagination in texts. When you meet in person, the feeling of "this is getting serious" arrives. A man who's afraid of commitment steps back right at this moment.
- Disappointment. Sometimes it's simply this: The person we built in our heads over text isn't the same as the one in front of us. And instead of saying it honestly, we act cold. Guys, this is the worst.
Serra: "So girls, don't you ever do it?"
I don't want to be unfair, we do it too. There are plenty of women who flirt all night over text and then give off a "We're really just friends" vibe when they meet. Sometimes we realize in person that we don't know what we want, and sometimes we've inflated the attention in the messages because we liked it.
Inconsistency isn't a gender issue. It's a matter of courage. Anyone who is bold on screen and hides at the table is doing the same injustice to the person across from them.
Kerem: "How can you tell real interest?"
Let me give women a few signs from the male side. A man who is truly interested:
- Suggests meeting himself. He doesn't just text for weeks. He wants to bring the conversation from the messages to the table.
- Keeps his phone in his pocket face to face. If someone who had so much to say on screen looks at their phone while you're sitting across from them, their interest is limited to the screen.
- Is consistent after the date. He says, "Today was great, let's see each other again," and gives a date. He doesn't send a long message at midnight and then postpone meeting the following week.
- The man in the messages and the man at the table are more or less the same. He may be a bit shy, a bit quieter; but he isn't cold.
Serra: "What should you do?"
Girls, here are my suggestions:
- Give one more chance, but only one. The first date can be nerve-racking. If the same coldness is there on the second date, the problem isn't nerves.
- Don't drag out the texting. You texted for two weeks, met once, and it was awkward; don't go back to the screen and text for hours. Measure by the meetings, not the messaging.
- Ask directly. "You were so different over text, and in person you seemed a little distant. Is something up?" This question doesn't scare anyone; if it does, that's your answer.
- Don't fall in love with the person on the screen. The warmth of late-night messages can deceive you. You'll build a relationship not with the person who writes those messages, but with the person sitting across from you.
Kerem: "Guys, a word for you too"
If you can't be in person as much as you write in your messages, either cut down on the texting or build up your courage. Writing "Talking to you feels so good" to a woman for hours at night and then looking at your phone at the table is making a promise to her and breaking it.
And if you didn't like her after the date, say so. Saying "It was nice meeting you but this isn't what I'm looking for" takes five seconds. Disappearing or acting cold takes weeks of her life.
Joint note
Serra: Girls, measure a person's interest not by their messages, but by how they are at the table.
Kerem: Guys, if you can't live up to the man you built on screen, don't build him at all.
Serra: And don't think we wrote this piece together, by the way.
Kerem: We were much more intimate over text anyway.
About the author
Related Posts
BLOGWhy can't men keep a girlfriend? This time Serra writes to the guys from women's point of view
BLOGGuys, Why Can't You Get a Girlfriend? Kerem Puts Down His Whiskey and Lays Out the Painful Truths
BLOGYou Asked a Slavic Friend for Relationship Advice: "I Think He's Unemployed." What Did I Learn? Serra Weighs In

Comments