Skip to content
Blonde woman with red lipstick sits in a purple armchair on a pink studio set, with a gold skull and glass on the desk.

Court rejects Ivana Sert's request for refund of 77,000 TL

Fashion designer Ivana Sert sued to recover the 77,000 TL she said she paid in 2018 over her former shop. The Istanbul Civil Court of Peace found the claim unfounded and dismissed the case.

2 min read

Court rulings and refund disputes often draw public attention on TV entertainment programs. Photo: İşte Benim Stilim / Wikimedia Commons

Well-known fashion designer Ivana Sert did not get the result she wanted in her lawsuit to recover 77,000 TL, which she said she paid in 2018 out of fear of seizure over her former workplace in Nişantaşı. The Istanbul Civil Court of Peace found her refund request unfounded and dismissed the case. The dispute concerned a 2012 lease for her former shop on Teşvikiye Street in Şişli and the enforcement proceedings that followed.

Left: blonde woman in black top before a pink TV backdrop. Right: blonde woman in red halter dress, hair blowing in the wind.
sozcucdn.com

Sert's argument: I paid out of fear of seizure

Sert claimed that enforcement proceedings were launched against her over unpaid rent, but that a problem involving her lawyer kept her from learning about the process in time. In her petition, she argued that the signature on the lease was not hers and that there was no guarantor or similar agreement between her and the creditor.

The designer said she paid 77,000 TL to the property owner, Vassaf Ç., in 2018 out of fear of seizure and asked for the money to be returned. She stated in her petition that the main reason for the payment was that fear.

The other side: The lease bears a commercial emblem

The defendant, Vassaf Ç., said in his petition that the lease carried Ivana Sert's commercial emblem. He said he started enforcement proceedings after the rent went uncollected for a long time, and argued that Sert did not object to the enforcement file within the legal period after paying, so the proceedings became final.

The defendant also claimed that Sert had accepted the contract in another case being heard at the Istanbul Commercial Court, and asked for the lawsuit to be dismissed.

The court's decision

The parties' lawyers presented their arguments to one another during the hearing. After reviewing the file, the Istanbul Civil Court of Peace found Sert's request for a refund unfounded and dismissed the case. The long-running dispute thus ended against the designer at the first instance.

With the ruling, Sert's refund request over the process that stemmed from the 2012 lease and ended in the 2018 payment found no support. No statement from Sert following the decision is known.

How did the process unfold?

In short, the sequence was as follows: a lease was dated 2012, enforcement proceedings were launched over unpaid rent, Sert made a 77,000 TL payment in 2018, and she later went to court to get that amount back. At the end of the proceedings, the court ruled that the refund request was unfounded. The file's long history shows how many years the dispute has lasted.

Comments

See All

Keep exploring

We use necessary cookies to run the site. With your permission, we also use analytics cookies to improve it, advertising cookies to show ads, and embed cookies to load outside content like videos. You can change your choice at any time. Cookie policy