
A Reply to Serra: Shall We Hear the Man Out in Slavic Advice Too? Cansu Defends Him
Serra had readers take notes on the viral "relationship advice from a Slav" video. Cansu looks at the same four scenes and asks one question: what does the man, the one everyone talks about but nobody lets speak, have to say?
Photo: Yapay zekâ ile üretilmiştir
Dear reader, last night I read Serra's piece. She took relationship advice from a Slav, took notes, and passed them on to the rest of us. I read it and laughed. Then something caught my attention.
In the video shared by @anyakurtini on Instagram, there are four scenes. In all four, a man is being talked about. The man who texts, the man who gets jealous, the man who likes "natural women," the man who won't pick her up from home. But in all four, the man himself is absent. What does he say, why does he act that way? Nobody asks.
I am the unofficial attorney of husbands, sons and boyfriends. I object to a ruling being made while my client is not present at the hearing.
Let me say this first: I have nothing against the girls in the video. The video is funny, the answers are clever, and I laughed while watching it. My objection is to our columnist turning these answers into a serious relationship lesson.
Let's open the files one by one.
File one: "I think he's unemployed"
The girl says: "He texts me morning and night, he wants to see me every day." The answer: "I think he's unemployed." And on top of that, Serra drew a lesson: "Ten minutes from a man with a full life are worth more than ten hours from an empty one."
Dear reader, now put your hand on your conscience. If a man texts little, he's "uninterested." If he replies late, he's "stringing you along." If he can't meet on the weekend, he's "not serious." And now if he texts all day, he's "unemployed"?
What is this man supposed to do?
I know there are men who are glued to their phones all day and have nothing else going on in their lives. But not every man who writes "Good morning" on his way to work, asks "What did you eat?" at lunch, and says "I want to see you" in the evening is idle. Some of them are simply thinking of you. And believe me, in this country the number of men who can show that openly is not that high.
My advice: before questioning the attention, remember how precious attention is. If you're wondering whether the man has a job, ask him. It's as easy as sending a message.
File two: "What if the next man buys you an apartment?"
The girl is jealous over her boyfriend. Her Slav friend reminds her of the apartment the next guy will buy. Serra called this "one of the smartest answers ever given to jealousy."
Dear reader, I see something else in this scene.
A woman is afraid of losing the man she loves. And what is offered as the cure for this fear? The next man and his title deed. In other words, the current man is a station, the next man is an apartment.
Now let's flip it. If a man told his friend, "I'm jealous over my girlfriend," and his friend said, "What if the next girl cooks better than her?", how would the article be written? Let me guess: under the headline "The mindset that measures women by the kitchen."
Let me give Serra her due on one point: don't see yourself as something that can be lost, that's right. But don't see the person across from you as something that can be replaced either. The cure for jealousy isn't the next man's wallet, it's an honest conversation with this man.
File three: "We like holding company owners too"
I liked this file the most, because this is where Serra got the most excited.
The man said, "I like natural women." Serra called it "not a preference, an instruction." The woman says, "We like holding company owners"; and that became a sentence "to be framed and hung on the wall."
Dear reader, may the same scale weigh both sides, please.
A man saying he likes women who wear less makeup is voicing a preference. You may not like it, it may not suit you, you can say "I love my lipstick" and move on. All of that is your right. But slapping the label "the man who is trying to change you" on him just because he said it is unfair.
And then answering with "We like holding company owners too"... Look, our Slav friend says we don't throw it in his face. True, we don't. But we say it in a video to hundreds of thousands of people and we all burst out laughing. The man gets a lecture for saying "natural," and we get applause for saying "holding."
My advice: don't hide your preferences, and don't treat his as a crime. Wear your lipstick, dream of the holding company. But don't condemn the man for saying "natural."
File four: "If the man isn't changing, the man is changing"
The girl asked her boyfriend to pick her up from home, and the man said, "Let's meet at the venue." Her Slav friend's verdict is final: "Someone will definitely want to pick you up. If a man doesn't change, a man is changing."
Dear reader, when I read this sentence I opened the map of Istanbul.
The man works in Kadıköy, the girl lives in Nişantaşı, the meeting place is Bebek. The man leaves work at six in the evening, gets on the bridge, reaches Nişantaşı, looks for parking, picks up the girl, goes to Bebek, looks for parking. By then it's nine in the evening. Then the same road back. At midnight he returns to Kadıköy, and in the morning it's work again.
Saying "Let's meet at the venue" isn't always indifference. Sometimes it's common sense, sometimes tiredness, and sometimes it's just Istanbul traffic.

Serra said something nice here, I won't deny her: "Ask first, maybe there's a reason." I agree. But before anyone asked, the video had already delivered its verdict: "If a man doesn't change, a man is changing."
So what if the woman doesn't change? The man says, "Let's stay home this weekend," and the woman wants to go out every weekend. The man says, "Will you come to Sunday breakfast with my family?" and the woman finds an excuse every time. What if we say "if a woman doesn't change, a woman is changing"? Let me tell you: the comments section would never close.
A relationship isn't a contest to fit one person's list to the other's. It's two people meeting in the middle. Sometimes you get picked up from home, sometimes you meet at the venue. The point isn't which is more romantic, it's that the two of you can talk about it.
A small note to Serra
Dear Serra, I enjoyed your piece. I also liked your fourth question: "Is my desire being heard?" It really is a good question.
But let me add a fifth question for you: "Am I hearing his desire?"
Because in all four scenes of this video, the woman talks, her friend answers, and the man isn't there. Maybe the man texts all day because he's in love. Maybe he likes natural women because his mother never wore makeup and she looked so beautiful to him. Maybe he wants to meet at the venue because he doesn't want to spend two hours on the bridge. We don't know. Because nobody asked him.
Cansu's verdict
Dear reader, take advice from your Slav friend, that's nice. But before passing judgment, listen to the other side too. Maybe the man isn't unemployed, just attentive. Maybe he isn't giving orders, just stating a preference. Maybe he isn't uninterested, just stuck in traffic.
If the man isn't changing, maybe let's ask him first. Then we can change him if we need to.
Source: @anyakurtini, Instagram
About the author
Columnist
Husbands' unofficial lawyer. In every divorce story she hears the man's side first, and most of the time she stays there. You won't be able to wrong men as easily as before, because now there is Cansu. Tell the truth and they'll chase you out of nine villages; Cansu keeps writing from the tenth.




Comments